Faaliyetler İş Araştırma ve İktisat Multicriteria Decisions • . ; ." Chaptet 17 Multicriteria Decisiofl5 -.~m..w.g • Goo.l Proglammlng: formul.~on ond C"pru.:ol Sol,,~on • Scoring Model5 • """I),Ii(Hiermrchy ~"IAHP) • E. t..blllhJng Priori~e. U.ing,o,HP ~~~ AHP to Devek>p on 0-".11 Priority R..nk;"g GO~I ~ro.gramtning Fonnula .~OI'1 St.p · l : o.H:id. ~he priori'J 1t,,;'1 eI.oeh ~l Step 2: Dedd. th ....... Igh l on e""h g~L . . ~ • ~. If 0 priority 1.".1 h .. "'C>n' than one 1 ... 1.10'" eACh gOloI; d.dd. tM weiVo~ ... ,.IobeJ>J.c.d On tt. deviatiOflI.) • .t,·ond/otd,·; b Olll !ht',ooL , . ~ .. ,-. -, .". Goal Programming • Gp!l prommmi"! 1'1'1', bo u_ \0 >01 .... lin ... progrom. with mullipl.objKri ...... w i ll> "..,h ob)Ktive v",wed a •• ·g ... I·. • In gool progromming. d, ond do .liui!lliII! .tl!YRIn. a •• Ihf amounu. l.I.ge~d gool i i. _ •• In .. pOop'Y 5oc"...,d ·priori'J pl,",e P"""~'~ without fPducing tho fifSl.pno.>ry goot •• plC • For .ath pnority 100".1 , 11>. obiecllv~ /unctiOf'l II \0 minim; .. tho (w.e;ghl.td) SUI'I'I DI IN. goo l o:I,,,;olk,,,,,. • P..,vOo". 'oplimal-.,h;. ... menb 01 goalS a ... ddelf to Ihf col\$lrO;n t ... , SO thot lhey ... ""t dpSradfd ... ru"" trying 10 orhi.~o I .... , pricriry SO&I •. H I with d , and d, or~ng .. IN. .... 'P I " . o"d-cdad J • - ..... -.~- ~ .... -~ -,- - ~~~~ "'-==' -:::!~.~""~===~.:..._-""-'-.J G9al Pr9grarnmiJlg F0nY1~a.ti0fl. fSti~ ' ''-Sel up u., inill,lli"" .. prog;"", .. Min ",d,' ' ",,4 .. " . ..... functio ... 1 C.ono".oint>, l " and Go.\ Co",,,oinl5 Step'" Solve Ihf C\UT .... t lin ... P'<'g'"no. . ~ .: . iJ ,lIlr~j,ol"""er pri~I)'~ye~I~ losteI!S. ::, '.:"_OIM~ I .... linal ooIutler> ha. beon .~d>ed. .; . , .' Goal Programming 'fonnulation s..p S, ' 501 ~fi the _ .... U .... " progr'm. COt\fid., Iho ..... I·k>w'" prioriI)' 1 __ 1 tool. and formulll.t. ~ 'obje(tI.e lunction b,~d on the~ goo l., Ju!n>traint>, and .. ,d,· • "'-Pi - l . . Gp iO.ltep 4,- rilep".i .~p. ' , 0"" S " nliflll pi;ori!, .:.: . In·l·~~· bHnu.mIMd .) . . ~ · 'suo . ··· .: __ ,. - .. :~ -:: -. '. ; '., '.: -: '., . ' :' : •. ?' -.' . ·.l .; . • , , ~ . ' ,: .llJedlsltdri ...... nd coo_ . .... bouafol ,..",., -00 ..... There ore l OOOCO d';~e .. 500 6p diolL.=' iri~ /:tOO (0'" noHatile to Concepb,o ol P.od", .. . on. weekly baoi,.. It l-oM. <>nr hoor.., mlnulocl,," 0 CP400.nd hs p.elil is S2OO.nd it l-o~ ........ onout'S to mon~IKtu ... Cr.;oo ond lIS p.-ofi! >s .,.,. ~ 0 1:OOO ___ w_"' ..... _.... ,..._ = ===- ~ .Cotlu-ptual ProdUCI$ .. ';"-:-" I , c.' Pri~\(eet • ~.~-':";'"oct eI 2IXl.9'~OO m"'hi .... ",..,kly .. (Gool l ) Priori.,. 1: Mah al koul5i'O 1 0101 ('Qmpute,. ....,kIy. IGoo-I1) Priooj!)' 3: MAkou .. ~. - ....... k.(Goal tl I .---.-~ __ ~ _. L ". ' . COllI Program~g: Formulation C • V. ri.blu ", • ~ .. ml>or 01 Cf'lOO ~""'pule" pro,h.ide 01 ,0.1 j l. uc...,ded • Juncllo ... lC""", .. InI.o · Anil&billty 0/ CD do1~u: h,' "~ 1000 Ay.il.bUity 0/ dp dl.k driye" ~,~ 500 .' Form .. :r::::r·:~}t:~~Ul ,~ti~n',l:1. Mi~ ',(d,). P,(d,')' P.J.~ I:. ' . ,1/,') "-l . ~" ~:::r,::·~:}-r~':~~'-;~~'~'f::: ' ''i ' 'Ji ' . . ,... . \; , .. ~ .": .600 "if,' . " ;. '-~I'~'· : .. ' .' , .. ,. - ;-·200 .i,. :-'~-.- ·'_ .. ~:~li ::'=J.l~:";',~ ; .. : __ ·· -~ :5"00: ··~::i~:: ' ':, .~, .t,:;d,' .I '-, d;"-::\:·-­ . ~~~?"-!;~ ·;e~:(c.,:~,-~',:_ji~;' .. ~:: :? _ :::"~ . ',. . . .... : -< :;; (( \~ :,~ ~!; \:: :,~~: .: ~:. :,': ~ .. :.~,: . '. CI.II.~""'- _.]Io,'oJI_."""'P-·_ .... " ,:.·,-~_u , --, .:~ ':',;: .~~ '- .::~~~_-.:o:.:r:-? -::~-::: --::-:-::: -::-::: -::-:-; . . :,--.{ ·) --{ ':{ ~'i :. , -~ , .{ -( : '-. ' . .' " ., '- " '-._-'-.~ .. :.', ,.'-. • I~n~on 2 ~' ~;~;~-~ ~ -: '. >.b: . NO ..... . dd~i.,~lOq.Ad i"p_h c;;.,.n, . "i ' I, - SOO.·" OIi' .... 1M' """,.tide ilia, lM.e I •• Iill.. ScI 01 poinl.o .. tidyln! tho fir. 1 ,.,.1 th.i .*'-"oti.f.n . thi. HCond 8001 (:--100 ... di - 0). -,, ' • _ Goob GfW P;ogramming: Formula tion C (1) l00CP400comp-~: ~, •• ,' ~i · d,' - :;00 • Il) S250(,,, lhou .. n.d.) p.-o/'I: ~, • .5~.'d,- • .t,'- 150 (4) 400 .clol rn . .... ~O\l" wnkly' ',' 1.5,.1,' ~ .. . d; - t OO No .... ne' .. i~;'Y: " · Il~r.lionl ' " .I ):'I,:-=1",;-:r "". ~: .. Gpal Prognmming:' . Gra~hicaISo!..-ti .on To""w " ' phic.olly, , ••• i ,,,p,, Ihe 1 ..... tio ... 1 COfI'r.;"" nl.o . . Then '''ph ~I!"i Itool;.,.-~ . .N.~ .... the nnl .lide 1".I ,Ill.~ 1, ... i.1 pp'n.!. 'hol .. coed " " 200 ( ... ~.~ 6,' • 0). - ', ' .,'" '._'- ',! 500 I -, sow ... ~ _. ; Goal Pro, gram min g: Formuhu'on ~ . , ' ~ " Objec~.e Funct. 01\J Pri .... 'Y , : Mi" in>iu lho .""""ni lhe .101 ...... tr.c' ;.""."",i: Mind,' PM""ry ), Minimiu tho number .. nd., 500 ..: 150. No .. On ,he nu l ~Iide_ thu ,,0 poin .. "ri.1y Ihe p,.v""" fu"clio,,~1 o:c,,"n;n" . nd gool • .!lld ,;"liIly th;>eon,I .. ;nl. . , n.uo. 10 M in fli. ,hi. minIm"", nh.e ;. och .. u d ... h .... w e Mn-b,' .s~,. NOl. \h.o , 'hio",",," 'i.l,· 200 . nd., - 400. 00 lho' .2...1, • $.w, - 140 ", . .s,'. 10. - ' -~.- - ~ 0,.. ___ w __ ".ar ............ 2 . ',' ..... , . ", Goal Programming: Graprucal Solution • ~Il ICo"ot>-.. I".) .nd Goo! 1 GJ'IIphod 1000 2.>, • 'I ! lCOO ~oring Model-ror Job SelKtion ' • . Contld.,;;'g only \Iv long'Plli ep;"n ~~,;~rion: • Th~ {WOO.! .""Inl m>a;itlon in l:llU.&9 i. tJ-,., be.f deCIsIOn .!~mo~.';. • Contid~!",g only tIw ~ 0;"':;"'" • n.. 'umyo"nt mUonin Qrriyri )i ~ Po~ deci~ .i,,":"Ii;"";. • CON;de~"gonly tIw I!).k . doub~ .... ;or in F ..... ,.,.,I.nc! Acco"nli"g hi .. ..aivld !he 10UowloS''''''' job oft .... • f\ro.n in""""'. n' ftr"'I"~so • ' «0",,11001 fo, I "'.nvf ....... ring 1;,,., in Den ..... • ."dito, for. CPA fi ....... in H<>u,'ao 01llOOn-Soo.od..w_ .... "''''._'''- . StePs Reqwred 1 0 ~ ... elop iI Scoring Model ", . . . .. . . '. . .. . . ~: "·S~jo':;: t.i .. ~Mo;isi"".m.king , . -.... · oJ~moli ..... "'.~.;.~~;,: ~~~:;~~:\".'~~~;~~.=::: :~:: ~~j' tIw -' -' -' " ": .. ;'.' = 1-- _. . rKtJmm._ .f""",';"", . ~onng Mod~l: Sl~ 2 Sorn.t .. "". ""'In,..,.\o'" """'-g,. I ",,..,.,,,"'"' . So""",,"'1 ;mp«\l"l V"ryl",poo-1.o,,1 -. """,,,, '.~ . Scoring Mod~t tor Job~I~(hO" .. n.., .. ud~n' m.d,. ,,,.. ronowing Commrn\S: ' ''n.., UNncl-I>fomrip> pat;""o providu Iho be., opp"rtuniry ro, my IonS'''''' CI' .... ' .d".""IOm.,,'.' • ~l woufd p,.fl' hin8 in Denvu ",ho, "'." In ChIc.go 0' Hou,'on,' • ~ I liko Lht man' g.m.n, . ryl,. ."d phllc:eo~.!...,,,t;he.Ho""QO CrA fi'''' tl>e be,t.' - --- . C~.;I~,lhJ .... : ",,,I.;,,.;,. ,;. ~.c.ia". . . . Scoring l'vIodel lor Job Sell.'('tion . . . . ' M.lhom'.licil Model rl- s ,- . '- f - o -',- '-,-' '~ .. " :';"8 !o~ C.~I<..:o,, ; .nd dm.i"" .I'r""'ti~ .. i. S, -lCOIefotd .. cioionoll~\an ' S Loc.bon Ave •• go ;m.,o''''''''' ""0"'8t_ Sorn.wNo. ''''POO-'''''' SoI.'Y A" ... gt ;mpo''''",,10 PIOUS' _ _ so ..... w "". unimp"' ..... ~,M<'Unl)l..:. Sotrnr-w"", imp"'''''' Enj<1'~"'.ly high ,,1 - ~ _ ....... w ....... AII~a-..¢ • . 0 j"'~""l\ ~:-i- :- ;-::- ~ :·:i:~:;:;:~~_~~~~~tt-:~·~rj,~;:~ - .s.-::-5(~)+;m;.(~+3¢i';~~~~~;~:;:~~~; <.: ... . -' _ .: .. :!. ::.". ~?~~~.:."j;.~~. ~:-t.,:~.~:: ,:.<:~. ... : \. \(\~ ~~: ~;::\:\~ \ ~\.- ~~. <~('-; ··om·;".,;,;...;,· ............. " .... ~:4i:a·;'i·!'·: ;"\tt~,. " '!.: ·t . - r' . ..:-·:·t : -i""'" :'.;'\'-'- '" ,~'.\"'·.r : .. ~ , -- ',' ~. -'-'~ : .. - ' . - . ~ . - .. ~ .' .. - . _ _ The AlIAlyt!c Hj";;;"hy P'PU'; fAt-iPl to ~ p~.o""" desired ~ ~V~ judg_nll ·oI~ ·~Ioti,,"impc*llncoClUd'i"''''''''''''I · . confUcllng oi"'ti. "ord in \he doodsion onaUng ptoc: .... Scoring Model: Step 3 ,s- o &t!I hew weU neh dec:lJion .h""""U"t ""liofioo.1itI: .. (hoit.rion.. ""'- 'Cat,.." .dv, ,,,,,,,,onL '-""-tion M"""go"'~nt S.1 .. y P,e.tig' jeb-..rity Entey.bl. we,k DKjIj!!D AlIr!l\!,ljvl AnairJl Aee""nlonl A .. dHor Q:liI:I.cg Pm.w: liluulP.n • • ,. . , . • , , -. . 9n'I~""'.~ . .@l .. .~ . . -. ·:25: '.- $(",", ' . . '-." -.:rs;:-. -... ',.\67, .. ~ .. ; ,-, , ., . ' ... continuod _. 0' Scoring Model: Step 4 .B • Ccmpvle It.. >cote fer .o<~ d~oion allemotiw. ~ C!1te";on W~;,hl ("") RalinS (" ') "'f~ CorM. adv'f>(~_nt '5 a 40 location . ) 1 9 M·""so ..... nl Solary Prr.tI&~ Job-.>rity [Norablt ..... ,k '" " " . .. _I~ '" 11-.:; <1_=, ""' = . =:C. =.;=:-=u""' ",.c::- = ~_ · __ . .= .. ",~ :....J Sco~n$ M.od~l: .SIIy 5 .: .. ~- : \na- :, o Dod" th< ilrd.ion a'li • .n.ti~u -".;;" ~g~'I<':: -r _on.." comp.lin! ,n ,I'r m.tivo .oIl), lI .. N _ Analytic Hierarchy P"XI'SS S..,.~: [).h..lop. prionlj M."", . Aher ",p. 2 tN°uS" 5 " .. loon" petl"or_d lor .ncri .. ria. lh. ~~I .. 01 ."'P 4 " .... """,,'-;~,d if>. pri<>Oity ;"'!rio h ~.tins -tho d~"" .i~""'ti~y'·; ­ "ori:tonlolly.nrl tho cril"n.o v.rtlally. Th. col"",,, ''!tri~."'" t!>' pri,!n..,. vKtoro It;>< .~ch'::rit.rio" . ~- ,- . . .... ~~~l7.~~ ibeConsis~ ~tio ~ -~ 4:" :;PUI. 'he ~.~ ·ii\~;~.n: 01 tho~ . .lt~mrilvuby' CI-p.,;,;;'''J/{~'l). . • S'op $-: - o.l.,."uJ>O u.., ""dom ",d_ Rl. 05I0Il .... " . SI~ Comp .. '" ,h_ con< p.i ...... .... comp.nlOn m."" by iI. cot"m" 'w"' . • 5,op 4: ~v.1op lit. PM"''''' V.cto< "'''''''go •• do 'ow 01 Ih. ".,."...liz." ...... i • . Th ... tt>W no .. s .. form th. pnan..,. .0<"'" 01 .ltemoll.e p"'I ... "" .... lth -, .. p.ct '0 th. parti cul., .. cri'orion. Tho v.I" •• in Ihi. v . ... '" ' um '0 I. 0 >000 ..-...-,.. ... w_", ~IOJ"'.', .... _ . An;,.lyl ic·Hier;udly Process .. , . . . . . . . -:·.c~,~,~ 1!' o.,v';- Iop ·, Crit""' r.i ......... o.v~l~minl · M .. ..;. ~ _. -:.. .. ~_ ,Jloio.i"AP1'o_'" 1M .. "' ..... n ... , OJ tho I .. ...-0:1 10 "_ " ..",ltr\Id . 1 ","':',;". poi .... ; .. c_"",ri&Or> ",.tric .. ..,. - . w~nS' .ubjorliv. ,.IinS' (.t.p 2). Si",il .. ly, normoHu .... . :~·th" ""Irlo l"~!) ond d~"olop. triton. prioriry _~. _.:.' ;" _~._-;.~ ~~ (,_ ,.,.0'_ .... ,' .. ,. .. ~" · -:'::'".;/.i~;;i o..;;"".on 0.-.,.11 Prionry VK _ _ .M~ltiply-Iho 'C7".ri~ priooily _to< (lrom .... p 7) by th. pnori ry .... t:ri.I""om ... p &) , ~ - -. ".'." - -' .. '! .. .~ ··i.·i . '-{'.j.'-' --, ', ,' .j . j ., \ .\ '" ' .. :." , .; . ~ .. ,.,:, .. ,~ ... ~:".~ I/~~.,:.· " ': .. ' .: Ex~ple: GiUC)a:ss o..;. ',"",. Gill.GI ... "'" .. decid®, .. wl\ich Df !lv.., ""'n~f.<:tutT .. will develop t.io,'.oI&,..tu",H . looO'rb",sI>e._ nu •• f.~'o", ... ;"'POf"'''' IDCil~ (1) h .. "".u: ~ ""nul.ct"' .... ot. Com.lllndu.t:riu, S"';'Pi ... -.,.d rkob~y. CcmrU lndu.1ri= ... ill .. 11 Ioolh~ loGiIlGl ... forS1OG,.... ~ Bru'" ~ I Pi). I." S80 pe' I,,,. .. . nd , ,,,oIour 10. Sl" p« ,'0". i <>;tOOo n.. s. ... w ....... "" .. p ...... "'.... SlOI, ,, I An~lylic Hienrt:hy Process • S, .. p 5: C.kul.le. Con,i.to..cy Ro,;o Th, . A COfl,;.'~ncy ,. rio '" .... ,IIon .l ~ ,oor!. F.,. ralloo .. hich.r-. "nt., Ilion .1. 'ho .~bjKtlvo inp'" ,houtd bo ...... n.lw ... d. _ _ Foo .. do ml.ri".", p"n .1.p.2 th,,,,,!h 5 ----- ..' '. ,. - """"' ''. DE'termj~i,!g the COnsi51ency Ratio • Step' ~ .F", uch , .... of u,o pc ....... ; .. coonp"''''''' ..... !ri., d .. enni .... _ w~il'''.d '''M..,. ."",,,,inS'1>o ,,",ultiplti. o>f Ih.. enlri<.'" 1M p""rily 01 i" COOT~opondi", (column) .I'.m.tiv •. • S"'p l: . .F~ oocl>~. diyld~ It~ ,...i,M.d 5Um loy lho­ pnoriry 0( ill. CDr",spol'din, I'ow) . It.m,livr. • 5~p]: ~_I"C th~_ .v ••• , •. l_ of ,h. rr.uh. 0/ .,.p 2, ;":-.' . .- S1Mk ,, ' . '7 \: . .,;""1.: .:. i , . .. 5 ", " ..•. ,- Pairwise Comparison Matrix~ Cost ~ em ho. d...::ld.e! th., in I.rm, of pna. Bn .. h Pi. ;" "...,.tu. t~ly p .... f.l"I. d '0 Cornello" d • • ry ~ I'",'o ..... d 10p",,,,,,,y_ In tu ... Com.1I i5 .... ""Sly 10"0'7 . lron&17 p~f.rnd '" Pica""r. " ·~orm~~_.Ma~ _C~t '~ ' . c: DI~ I!,~ ~ ~nI;" .';' Ih~ P-''''';'''': <9;"p~~n : ': ""' tri. by', .. connpondinS cOlu ';'" ;...,;. ro" - u.omp " . f""ea....u tn<<<>1 .. "", ... m - 1 _J' 1/6 -~S/6. ~ &i"'O: Co ... , 1 1 Bnuh Pik Pi«>~uy :C~U "" 7/11 j/If. "Noh Pi. -' 'l1/2S " 21/3] . :7J l~':- ~;e.;buy "" lrrr: lj1~ ' '-.. :... - .. OIeding :C~islenCy ~.: ~&;~ 'bOv. rtsul!s IOSelk_ ).,..,;-15.oM"'"..-s-.~ 3.029)/3 - ) ,)In -. -_Comp~ •• ;N'~~i ... nClO b>d.~ ~ lor two ''';''''~ CI · " l l._ - ")/'1" -1) " (3.101- 3)/1 - ,051 • Comp .. '" ,k.con.i ... fIC)' ;'lIo. ell. by CI /R1. wh.o •• RI - .51100- 3 I.do"" c~ - CI/RI - .oS I /..51 - .DIlI 5, .... .in.d by I v"o,!,n, 'w"o" .~Iri0 ... " .... too . by th.i<. p";"";Iier. 10 I.t: . • . .....:.... ~~rw~CO~p~r~50n MatriX~ . --_ .:: .. ',- :.~ ·R~ltablll l)' . ~ _ . c;...- , ___ i"ilo.-- l'ic';"~y ,- - .• , . .2 1{7 1 ~ l/1 l i S - '., ' 6 .: '.; . . .., -. Nonnaiil'.('d MaIn:.: ~ Reli~bility ~ Divide each entry In 11>0 1' ....... ; .. compo"""", ..... tri. l»'its~.Sct>l"""' ... m_ ro< .>..IImpl.,''''' Com .. n the «>lulJ'l" '~m _ 1 • II? , 1/2 -13/14. nu. &i"e.: co.-a 8 ...... Pi!. Picob"y Co,noll HIll l5/U 218 BN. h f';~ 2f2l 5/(1 SIS P;cob .... _, .+,'21 1/'1 1/1 Pairwi~compan. -son Matrix~ ,". OeJi\leryTime ~ CameU , , 8 ..... 0/> Pilo. l'~ '" • P~U1 , '. '. . ... ~ .. }~ ~.~. · • . ~,c.;' ~::~ Mauh~ _ __ I.bud . "'"'\i.nedlhoo' -...... of Qi!!.I:Y.. a>ol"-.truody p",r ••• bI. 10 ·de);""iy I~ y" " ' 1rd< nonnot; .. d molri.>o . Con .... bR& 10 dtdJno\t we S'" ! comd l :. ' !lIn3 - lS/'1- 2JI)f) • ["'J 8Noh P,k: ( 2/13+ SJ41. 5/1}!) • .Z71 !'leob"1: (7/ 21' 1/41' IfIll) • . 151 • Ct.ed.lna Con.ille""Y Gill GI ... • ~.ponH. 1 0 t.~.b;lj'Y could lor d>ock.d ' .... conNl.ncy _in the Mm . .... nn.' .. ",., Pik. . _ _ w-. • • a;p. ......... . Pnority VCO:lor; Oi;li"ery Time '. - !e n.f,'priOnly""""" is d.I~ .... ;Md by ov ... ~n8 Ill. ro ... n ..... in I~ """ .... 1~"'" "'obi~. Coft~.rlint 10 d";,...I, w. S." . CornrU: (8/ 11 . 8/11- 1/17)/3 • [.471] BryodoP,. ; (1/I1 ·lJl1.1/17)/3 - .059 P'<<>b<.or (8/ 11 . ' / 17.1/17)0 - .411 • C heel ln, C" .... ;.~no;y GiLl Clo" f~pon_1<> dO'l;yery ~..,.. <0..1<1 boo chod..d I.,. <0fMI" .. ""')' in " .......... "'.n ..... os ..... . ""l . . . ..... .-Normali;u?d Matr!x: .," I 1/17 1/1 7 .-:.,. 7 .;- '. Priority Vector: Cri,eri~ n.. priori.,. ~«1Ot b o:I~'~rmin~d hy .v~"Jln& !he rOW ~ u... ~ ... "",lized .... Iri>o. Co~ 1 0 d..:irn. l~ we B~" c~ ~Ii.bmty, ~Bve'l' : (103/ 19 . t9/~1 ' 9117)/3 - [ "'j ( 9/79 ' '/S7. 7/17)0 - .216 ( 7/79 . IJS7 ."1117)/3 - .05S ., .... ---~ .. " .... "'- End of Chapter 17 . ' .~ "," .............. . . ", - . . • __ ...:..... .... "¥'.,.,.... ... ...... '. . - - -~ '.' :'.:,' ", '. ~ ' 0 •• ': . . - '- .. -,,:;-~ _ . Overall PriOri,)' Veo:tor ~ The ""r •• !1 pnDriu ...... d.'e"";,,. " by ..... I~ply; .. 'u.. prioriI)' ytctof "'th. c:ril~rt. by Ih~ prioli~e. ,." •• d> dodo;"" ;,hi"".Ii"., ' Of .. ~h obj<'ctivr. Prl<>rily Vr.:!OJ r.-=~--;""'--O=;-71 I..,. en,"," ! I .719 ' .116 laS I I 8nuh Plk :, ~'. . . . - : . - '," , " .. ·,::;.t,";:M(t{\;;,s::;:/, ', ',' -- ::~ :'.'~~~:~·~;:J~~~1f.f9-:~~-~;·.1·· r ; : . - .. .. -, ':-:. ' .. : :'';~'<~;:: .- ::::.~::;:: .. .. " .: :-: " .; .~;':':; -:':"~'.; .~ . ~ -- . ..- . , Overall Priority Vec tor ~ n.u" Il>r ""enll priSll .471)- ['~j l B",.h P;\ : (J'9)(.632)' (.111>)(.278) - j.05S)(.O'i9j.., .514 pk obuy: (.72'1)(.ll69) ' (:1!6l(.lSl) ' j..lY.>S)( .4])) · .109 Bot ... ' jk ' p"'''''0 h tbt 0YrI'!! 'KpmmtDd.!lon .... ". " . ... ,. ; .... , -. -'- .. '. 8